quote:
Originally posted by Wolfson:
I agree with you in terms of your definition--that's why I used the word "assuming." (...) On the other hand, I'd also have to assume that there are, in fact, people who derive sexual pleasure from the graphic depictions in hentai bishoujo. I could be wrong, but you never know...
Though you might not be doing this, the only problem even using the act itself, rather then those involved in the act taking part in the act, to say if people derive sexual pleasure from seeing the graphic depiction of the act it is porn, is you cannot link it to just bishoujo games. Such an idea then has to be made part of the entire definition and doing so means every 'R'-Rated movie might end up being called porn since those people might find the sexual acts seen in those movies to be a source of pleasure thus using that to say if the games are porn means not just the games but many other things become porn. Basically a similar problem to what already exists.
Perhaps if you combine the people/characters with the act only where the act occurs almost every other scene, such as both of the Do You Like Horny Bunnies games, that could be considered porn since they are along the same lines as what Nandemonai was mentioning. However this is different since the act is continual and considering the people or characters involved realizes that might not be exciting to people with different characters involved.
So to apply the definition I think you have to keep the people/characters tied to the act, and see the frequency rather then just universally apply the definition to any game with nudity or sexual depictions, which it seems you are not doing at this time, but which is being mentioned in this thread.
[This message has been edited by SCDawg (edited 06-27-2004).]