@Murderous Int: Ok, I was prepared to drop the subject, but your hypocrisy has reached levels that surpass mere irritation.
Shiki, Shiki, Shiki, Shiki. Why is it that this has become a vendetta against me? If you have a problem with me, just say it. Don't hide behind a simple disagreement over acceptable standards of editing. And don't act like I've somehow slighted you. I suggested that making a big deal about typos in a title most everyone seems to be enjoying thoroughly was being a bit of a spoil sport. When pressed about it, I asked for evidence that the problem was as bad as you claim--evidence that would've taken you all of 5min to produce, much less than the time you've spent bickering with me unproductively in this thread. At no point did I tell you to take your complaints elsewhere. I took your personal attacks like an adult til now because honestly I didn't think it was worth derailing this thread just to bicker with you. But now I see you're SIMPLY NOT GOING TO LET IT GO until I confront you and we have this out. Sorry JAST, but this is your fault for not having proper moderation in place. Sorry Starless fans, but I'm not just going to stand by while Murderous Int keeps slandering me unchecked. This argument is completely, 100% his fault.
"Unless you too have played the game and looked and the silly amount of mistakes, why are you commenting on this issue? But it's okay.... I mean it is just Starless who cares?"
What does this have to do with what Rooke said? You're just taking another shot at me. Starless is a high-profile title that deserves the same amount of attention as any other high-profile game. BUT as a nukige the focus of that attention should be different. The image problem was a more pressing issue for a nukige. For a story-focused title, maybe the typos would be the more pressing issue that should be fixed first. It all comes down to what customers care about the most. For story-focused titles, I'd gladly sacrifice demosaicing to get something else I want. Would you say the same about nukige?
"Before JAST gave a response I wanted people to help log the issue and JAST to confront it. but Shiki wanted me to prove shit to him in his specific criteria and prove myself to him after I criticized him for saying that they aren't minor, and that it's okay to justify it the case of MG but not JAST."
Bla, bla, bla, Shiki. Can't you argue without insulting other people while doing so? No, that would require you to grow up.
As I already stated, I asked for you to justify your claims to convince people who haven't played this game that they should care. People like me. People like Rooke. You think I'm going to slap $40 down just to validate your whining as a real quality control concern that JAST should be taken to task for? I don't care about Starless. But I do care about Shiny Days. And actually, I care about Raidy 3, which is a nukige. I'd prefer both titles not be ridden with typos. But you can't get me (or others like me) to care unless you actually prove to me (and others) that this is an issue. You'll have to wait until we play those other titles and start complaining. Why not convince us NOW, while the game YOU care about is in the limelight? Or would you prefer to wait til Shiny Days comes out, it's ridden with errors, and I write an article condemning JAST for it? Then you could complain about me playing favorites, right? Because bitching about me is more important than the actual issue at hand?
"it's okay to justify it the case of MG but not JAST."
Not really. Different types of errors. And actually, you might notice that I was pretty dismissive of the issues Rooke had with Princess Evangile. A non-nukige, I might add. Sorry for being hypocritical again.
"If you look, my first post on QC issues on Starless, it was me who brought up the zoom issue. "
Congratulations, do you want a cookie? I already gave you your due, even though I was really aggravated with you. I think that shows who's the adult here.
"The volume is silly, and do they think it's worth us posting 10 pages, will they address it or will they let us sort it out?"
It was never worth you posting 10 pages of screenshots, and that was a pointless endeavor to begin with. There's two steps to achieving your goal to get these typo issues fixed.
1) Establish that a problem exists. You don't need 100 screenshots to do this. Probably less than 10, together with an estimate of frequency, would suffice.
2) Get JAST to fix it, or fix it yourself. Again, hundreds of screenshots don't really help. The game either gets an editing pass (by either JAST or fans), or it doesn't. No one in their right mind would use screenshots as a basis for fixing typos.
"Your post is off point, you should BUY THE GAME first and play it before coming in with a list of reason on why I justify Shiki 101 who also didn't BUY THE GAME. :P"
Did Rooke mention me once? I don't think he did. Did he take my side? I don't think he did. You're the one who keeps insisting this is all about me. Are you that infatuated with me that you hang on every word I say and redirect every argument to be about me? Grow up!
"If you notice Shiki behavior about this is"
...
"a list of reason on why I justify Shiki 101"
...
" but JAST make it harder for people to represent them when they are offering something which isn't up to the standard of other stuff they have released."
"I give credit where it is due and want JAST to do well but I won't cover for a blatant balls up on the QC compared to other stuff they released"
Weren't you complaining to me earlier that JAST's releases are inconsistent in their editing quality? Maybe I'm simply misremembering? Sorry, I was supposed to be the hypocrite, right?
"I wonder if JAST will skimp on Shiny Days QC and if it will be riddled with silly mistakes"
You finally appealed to an external audience that would help bolster the support for your cause. Congratulations!
", but some how I doubt that, but you never know."
And then you ruined it with an unfounded accusation of favoritism! Well, I had a split second of hope for a minute there.
It takes a special kind of insecurity to post the kind of nonsense you've demonstrated here. How about you grow up and we go back to discussing VNs like mature adults, hmm? My demeanor can be off-putting, but I find there's very few people I can't get along with. Even grgspunk and I have our moments of solidarity.